automated-trading.ch

Candle Range Theory (CRT) Strategy

NinjaTrader 8 Strategy Published 16 March 2025
PREMIUM
Summary

The Candle Range Theory (CRT) Strategy is a Premium mechanical strategy for the NinjaTrader 8 platform The strategy can be used to pass propfirms evaluation challenges

We highly recommend joining our discord community by following this invite link discord-invitation

Index
Entry Setup Criteria

This strategy has one entry setup that is based on Candle Range Theory (CRT) mehodology

To resume, the CRT entry model is a high probability entry model with a defined risk reward ratio. This entry model is based on analyzing candle pattern on a Higher timeframe and looking for entry confirmation on the lower timeframe.

On the Higher timeframe we are looking to identify a CRT candlestick pattern which is a pattern that respects the Accumulation, Manipulation, Distribution sequence. The image below illustrates a perfect short CRT entry model, where you have 3 candles on the higher timeframe:

  • The first candle is a long accumulation candle
  • The second candle is a manipulation candle where the price creates a wick that goes above the prevous candle high but goes back down and closes inside the body of the previous candle.
  • The third candle is the distribution candle where the price breaks the previous candle lower wick and goes into hitting the first candle low and beyond

sbs-definition
Click to enlarge

So as you can see the entry trigger for this entry model is the break of the lower wick for the 2nd candle. The trigger for a trade entry is analyzed on a lower fast timeframe, for example if the CRT candle model is observed on a 1 Hour timeframe, we may look into an entry confirmation on the 1 Minute timeframe or the 5 Minute timeframe.

We use a lower timeframe for entry confirmation to be able to properly enter the trade on a timely manner, for that we can use an FVG (Faire Value Gap) to enter, or simply wait for a lower timeframe to close below the lower wick of the 2nd candle. Of course you will need to inverse everything for a Long entry model

One good thing about this model, is that the take profit/stop loss ratios can be knwon before entering the trade. In general, the stoploss should be put some ticks above the manipulation candle (2nd candle), and the take profit target can be the low of the 1 candle.

Chart Examples

So let's look at some real examples on the chart:

These examples are not intended to show that the strategy generates profit. I have intentionally handpicked profitable trades to avoid confusion and to show the best case scenarios where the entry setups work well. If you run the strategy on your side, you will see that many of those same entry setups will lead to losing trades. This is the reality of trading. Your goal should be expected profitability on the long run even though some trades are in loss.

MES 1 Minute - 1 Hour Higher timeframe
CRT-MES-Minute1
Click to enlarge

In this example, we are on MES 1 Minute Timeframe. The higher Timeframe is the 1 Hour timeframe. You can see the higher timeframe candles drawn as an overlay which is very useful. This example has two seperate entries. The first one, is a long entry, the second one is a short entry.

The 1 and 2 markers show the 2 candles that generated the entries. whereas the TP and SL markers show where the take profit and stoploss levels are set.

MES 1 Minute - 1 Hour Higher timeframe - 2x CRT candle take profit
CRT-2x-profit
Click to enlarge

This example illustrates the usage of a 2xCRT candle take profit. The strategy allows to select many Take profit and stoploss strategies. The default take profit of the CRT method is set to the high/lower wick for the first accumulation candle. But this can be extended to a 2x factor which is illustrated in this example. The 1X shows where the first take profit level is, the the 2X shows where the 2x take profit level was set. This produces a higher expectency of profit on the long term.

Features

The CRT strategy has a set of unique features:

  • Robust In-house implementation of the Candle Range Theory Entry setup algorithm
  • No pending orders are placed: only market orders which produces no cases of rejected orders or partial fills
  • Full-auto strategy that can be scaled into multiple instances
  • Precise backtesting capabilities following NinjaTrader official best practices to obtain precise entry/exit backtesting on tick level intrabar granularity
  • Robust In-house Order management library. Resistant to connection loss and works seamlessly on Rithmic accounts or NinjaTader brokerage accounts
  • On chart command buttons to manually manage the positions in case it is needed
  • Very lighweight strategy that can be run on multiple instances even on low power VPS

Here I further explain some of the features of the strategy in more details

Dynamic Quantity and Risk Management

As all our strategies, this strategy implements two methods to set quantity for open positions.

  • Fixed Quantity: This method will use the same quantity value for each position. If the stoploss is variable between positions (by using a dynamic stop loss value), The win/loss will be also variable between positions
  • Dynamic Risk Adjusted Quantity: This method will calculate quantity of each position based on multiple factors:
    • The stoploss of the position
    • The maximum risk (in $ currency value) allowed for a position to take
    • The maximum quantity allowed for a position to take
    Using this method will produce equal win/loss amounts accross all positions. For example, a position with a tight stoploss will have a greater quantity than a wide stoploss position, so that both positions produce the same profit or loss
Position Management

As all our strategies, this strategy implements mutiple position management methods :

  • ATM Strategy:If you wish to delegate the position management to your own ATM strategy, this is possible by selecting an ATM strategy of your choice from the drop down box
  • Dollar Cost Averaging:This method will manage the position by increasing the quantity of the position if the price goes into the losing side. By doing that the strategy aims to bring the average price of the position closed to the current price and close the position on breakeven when the price pullbacks
  • Classic Trailing Stop:This method will trail the stop loss based on a configurable trigger and amount

Apart from those position management methods, the strategy allows to set the stop loss based on multiple strategies and to set the take profit based on a ratio based method. Check the parameters section for a detailed explanation

Account Management

The strategy implements daily stop-trading triggers based on the Net winning position count, the Net losing position count or when a target realized Net profit is reached. or when a target net loss is reached.

Parameters

We try to keep the parameters to minimum. We only left the most important parameters to be set

General
Execute Historical Trades This parameter is very important and should be used carefully. This parameter should be set to true (checked) whenever the strategy runs in Historical, Backtest, or Optimization modes. When running the strategy in Live Real-Time mode this parameter should be set to false (unchecked).
Daily TakeProfit Target The strategy will stop when the daily TakeProfit amount is reached after a position is closed. When set to 0, this parameter is ignored
Daily StopLoss Limit The strategy will stop when the daily StopLoss amount is reached after a position is closed. The value of this parameter is positive. For example if the value is set to 300, the strategy will stop when the Realized PnL is lower or equal to -300$. When set to 0, this parameter is ignored
Stop @ Winning Count This will make the strategy stop trading if the net count of winning trades for the day is equal to the value of this parameter. This parameter is ignored if equal to 0
Stop @ Losing Count This will make the strategy stop trading if the net count of losing trades for the day is equal to the value of this parameter. This parameter is ignored if equal to 0
Render Opacity (1-100) The opacity to render objects on the chart. I personally prefer the value of 70 for this parameter
Execute on Different Instrument The parameter will enable executing trades on another instrument than the one on the active chart. This can be useful if you sant to run the strategy logic on Minis and execute on Micros to better manage the risk by opening the trades on Micros. Notice that if you enable this parameter all the risk calculation done by the strategy will be made on the execution instrument. And notice also that since the instrument on the chart is not the execution instrument you will not see order execution history on the chart.
Execution Instrument The parameter will let you chose from a list of Micros available on your NinjaTrader connection, the instrument on which trades will be executed. notice that historical trades and live trades will Not be displayed on the Chart in this case.
Market Structure
Higher TimeFrame This parameter allows to select the higher timeframe on which the entry setup analysis will be run. Make sure to select a higher timeframe in regard of the current timeframe on the chart. Make sure to select a timeframe of the same type of the timeframe on the active chart. For example you cannot select a "Tick" based higher timeframe while the current chart timeframe is "Minute"
Higher TimeFrame Period This parameter sets the period of the higher timeframe
Entry Setup
Time Zone

This parameter sets the time zone to be used for setting the Trade Time parameter below. Since futures markets are open and closed based on US market time zone which is EST (US Eastern, New York), this parameter allows you to specifiy trade time interval on another timezone which is your local machine timezone

  • EST: This will use EST (Eastern Time) timezone while setting the Trade Time intervals
  • CET: This will use CET (Centrel European Time) timezone while setting the Trade Time intervals
  • Local Time: This will use the local machine timezone
Trade Time

This parameter is very important and can be delicate in some cases. This parameter is used to specify the time intervals in which the strategy is allowed to place trades. Here are some examples for more clarifications:

  • EST timezone and trade time should be set to RTH (regular trading hours): use the value 09:30-16:15
  • Machine in Switzerland Time Zone and and timezone is set to local, trade time should be set to RTH: use the value 15:30-22:15
  • EST timezone and trade time should be set to both RTH and ETH (extended trading hours) with gaps to avoid volatile periods: 00:01-08:00,09:55-15:55,18:01-23:59
  • In this example, there are two things to notice: The time intervals should be set in increasing order even though the last interval 18:01-23:59 is the first interval that occurs for a new day session. The time interval were cut at midnight to avoid issues when stepping into a new day
  • Machine in Switzerland and Time Zone set to local and trade time set to both RTH and ETH (extended trading hours) with a gap to avoid volatile period: use the value 00:01-14:00,15:55-21:55
Quantity Strategy

This parameter sets how the quantity should be set for a Trade

  • Fixed Quantity: This will set a fixed quantity. Before the trade is open, the risk is evaluated and if the risk calculated is higher than the value of the parameter Target Risk Per Trade ($), the trade is skipped and will not be open
  • Risk Adjusted: this option will make the contract size for each trade dynamic and calculated based on the StopLoss price and the Target Risk Per Trade ($) value
Max Qty This parameter sets the maximum allowed quantity when the Risk Adjusted method is selected. This option is very useful since some propfirms has order quantity limits that can cause the account to be invalidated
Long/Short Entry Mode

This parameter is useful if you already have a directional daily bias and want to restrict trading to a specific direction long or short

  • Long: Only long trades will be open
  • Short: Only short trades will be open
  • Long & Short: The strategy will open both long and short trades
Trade Entry Mode

This parameter sets the entry mode after a valid SBS sequence is detected

  • Immediate: This option will trigger a position immediately when the price breaks the high/low wick of the first CRT candle by a minimum of one tick
  • FVG: This option will wait for an FVG to form when the price breaks the high/low wick of the first CRT candle
Min CRT Ticks This parameter sets the minimum amount in ticks of the CRT candle that represents profit area to be taken. If this area is very small, it means that the trade is not worth taking. This is why this parameter is useful to skip CRT candles where the distance in tick from the entry signal to the take profit wick is very small
Min CRT Ratio The CRT ratio is defined as the ratio between two distances:
  • The distance from the trade entry signal to the take profitwick (high wick of the 1st CRT candle for Long, and low wick of the 1st CRT candle for Short)
  • The distance from the trade entry price to the stop loss wick (low wick of the 1st CRT candle for Long, and high wick of the 1st CRT candle for Short)
If this ratio expresses the win:loss ratio of the trade. This parameter will make you adjust the minimum ratio allowed and thus skip entries with small ratio meaning skipping entries with very small win:loss ratio
SuperTrend Entry Filter This parameter will enable/disable using the SuperTrend indicator as an entry filter. When this is enabled, Long trades are allowed to enter only when the SuperTrend is in bullish mode. Inversly, it allows short trades to enter only when the SuperTrend indicator is in bearish mode
Order Qty This parameter is only used if the Quantity Strategy is set to Fixed. This parameter sets a fixed quantity of each trade. In the case of increasing orders quantity executed by the order management mechansim, this parameter is also used for each increase in quantity. Generally, We would use the values 1 or 2 for this parameter
Super Trend
This section is visible only when the SuperTrend Entry Filter parameter is enabled
SuperTrend Mode
  • ATR: This sets the SuperTrend mode to ATR based calculation
  • Adaptive: This sets the SuperTrend mode to an adaptative mode based on candle Close, High, Low
Period This sets the supertrend period
Multiplier This sets the Supertrend multiplier. The bigger this parameter the wider the superstrend bands
Moving Avg. Type This selectes the Moving Average type for Supertrend
Smooth This sets the smoothing period of the supertrend
Order Management
Order Management Strategy
  • ATM Strategy:

    This method will trigger an ATM strategy to which it will entirely delegate the management of the position

    The ATM (Automated Trading Management) strategy is a mechanism provided by NinjaTrader that can be accessed from the Chart Panel

    When this method is selected, you should specifiy the template name of the ATM strategy to use and the positions opened will be managed by your custom ATM strategy

  • Dollar Cost Averaging (Grid): This method will increase the order quantity each time a swing is formed in losing side of the trade, which creates a dollar cost averaging effect on the position average price. We also call this a Grid method
  • Classic Trail Stop:

    This method will run a trailing stop based on a trigger and a trailing amount. See below for the Trailing Stop Parameters for parameters that control this method

  • None: This selection means the stop loss defined by the Target Risk Per Trade ($) parameter will be used
ATM Strategy Template Name

This parameter is available when the ATM Strategy order management method is selected. This parameter specifies which ATM strategy to use.

As in the image example above, the value of this parameter should be the template name of your custom ATM strategy. In the example is should be equal to template1

off course you can chose another name, but the most important thing is that the parameter value should correspond to an existing "ATM strategy template" otherwise no position will be opened

On Opposite Signal
  • Breakeven: This parameter sets the behaviour of the strategy whenever an opposite signal occurs to breakeven
  • Close Position: This parameter sets the behaviour of the strategy whenever an opposite signal occurs to immediately closing the position
  • DoNothing: This parameter sets the behaviour of the strategy whenever an opposite signal occurs to nothing
Enable Price Breakeven This parameter will enable/disable breakeven mechanism based on price
Breakeven Price Strategy This parameter sets how the price based breakeven should be calculated
  • Points: The breakeven will be triggered based on points
  • Percentage: The breakeven will be triggered based on percentage of take profit reached
Breakeven Price Trigger This parameter is available if Price based Breakeven is enabled This parameter sets the trigger value that needs to be reached in order to set the stoploss of the current position to breakeven
Enable Time Breakeven This parameter will enable/disable breakeven mechanism based on time in minutes
Breakeven Time Trigger This parameter is available if Time based Breakeven is enabled This parameter sets the trigger value in minutes that needs to be reached in order to set the stoploss of the current position to breakeven
StopLoss Strategy
  • CRT candle: The StopLoss price is set to low wick of the CRT candle for long entries. And is set to high wick of the CRT candle for short entries
  • Fixed Currency Value: This selection means only the stop loss defined by the Target Risk Per Trade ($) parameter will be used
  • Points: The StopLoss price is set as a number of points from the entry price
TakeProfit Strategy
  • CRT Candle:
  • 1.5x CRT Candle:
  • 2x CRT Candle:
  • 3x CRT Candle:
  • Fixed Currency Value: This selection means the take profit price will be based on the fixed value of the parameter Take Profit Currency
  • Points: The take profit price will be set as a number of Points from the entry price
  • 0.75 Win Loss Ratio: The take profit price will be set the 0.236 Fibo level taken from Swing3 to the opposite extreme point of the sequence
  • 1:1 Win Loss Ratio: The take profit price will be calculated based on the stop loss price with a 1:1 ratio
  • 0.5:1 Win Loss Ratio: The take profit price will be calculated based on the stop loss price with a 0.5 ratio
  • 1.5:1 Win Loss Ratio: The take profit price will be calculated based on the stop loss price with a 1.5 ratio
  • 2:1 Win Loss Ratio: The take profit price will be calculated based on the stop loss price with a 2:1 ratio
  • 3:1 Win Loss Ratio: The take profit price will be calculated based on the stop loss price with a 3:1 ratio
  • 4:1 Win Loss Ratio: The take profit price will be calculated based on the stop loss price with a 4:1 ratio
  • 5:1 Win Loss Ratio: The take profit price will be calculated based on the stop loss price with a 5:1 ratio
  • 6:1 Win Loss Ratio: The take profit price will be calculated based on the stop loss price with a 6:1 ratio
Target Risk Per Trade ($) This sets the max risk in dollars for one position.
  • This parameter is used before a position is open to determine if the StopLoss level calculated by the StopLoss Strategy respects this max risk, if not, the position will not be opened
Max Allowed Risk Per ($)
  • This parameter is only used if the Quantity Strategy parameter is set to Risk Adjusted
  • When the quantity is calculated based on a StopLoss level and a target Risk in $, the calculated quantity will be the quantity that gets as close as possible to generating the target Risk for the given stoploss, but rarely the exact target Risk. So for example if you set the Target Risk to $250, the strategy will calculate the quantity of 3 for example. This value of 3 will generate a real risk of lets say 257$ (in an ideal setting the quantity would have been 2.89 to generate exactly $250 risk, but that is impossible). So this parameter will control how far you allow the real Risk to deviate from the Target Risk.
Stop Loss Points This parameter is available if the Stop Loss strategy is set to Points
Take Profit Currency This sets the take profit in dollars for the open position. If you use the Fixed Currency Value as a take profit strategy, the value of this parameter will be used. If not, make sure to set this parameter to a high value to not interfer with other ratio based strategies
Scale out % Qty at % Target This option will enable a scaling out mechanism that consists in closing a percentage of the position quantity when the price hits a certain percentage of the the profit target. The value calculated is rounded to the lower value if the percentage value calculated is fractional. For example, if the position is a 5 quantity positions, and the quantity percentage of this parameter is set to 50%, the quantity closed will be 2 (lower end of 2.5)
Scale out at % Target This parameter sets the percentage of the profit target that will trigger the scaling out mechanism
Scale out % Qty This parameter sets the percentage of the quantity that will be closed during the scaling out mechanism
Take Profit Points This parameter is available if the Take Profit strategy is set to Points
Trailing Stop Parameters
Trailing Stop Strategy When the Classic Trail Stop method is selected, this parameter let you chose on which basis the trailing will be calculated
  • Points: The trailing trigger and trailing amount will be calculated in Points from the entry price
  • Ratio: The trailing trigger and amount will be calculated in ratio from the stoploss value mirrored on the winning side of the trade
Trailing Stop Trigger When the Classic Trail Stop method is selected, this parameter sets the trigger (in Points or in Ratio)
Trail Amount When the Classic Trail Stop method is selected, this parameter sets the amount (in Points or in Ratio) to be trailed when the trigger is hit
DCA (Grid) Parameters
Breakeven Profit Shift When the DCA method is selected as a position management method, this parameter will modify the definition of a breakeven and adds a bit of profit to it. This is useful to cover the cost of commissions when closing the grid in breakeven
Grid Size to Breakeven When the DCA method is selected as a position management method, this parameter will set the number of order increases required to consider closing the position in breakeven
Min Grid Gap (Point) When the DCA method is selected as a position management method, this parameter defines a minimum gap disstance in points between two orders
Bar Close Trigger When the DCA method is selected as a position management method, this parameter will make grid orders open on bar close in the direction of the trade
Command Buttons
The strategy allows to manually execute some commands in case you want to manually intervene. The commands buttons are added to the Chart Trader panel, make sure to show it on your active chart
Arm/Disarm Buttons The Arm Long/Disabled Long and Arm Short/Disabled Short buttons can manually activate or deactivate entering trades long or short. By default those two toggle buttons are enabled meaning the strategy is armed to enter both long and short trades. Toggling the button to the disable will restrain the strategy to enter a trade in the disabled direction. This can be useful if you have a directional bias or conviction about the direction of the market
Close Position Button The Close position button will immediately flatten the position on the active instrument on the active Chart. This can be useful if you want to exit a trade without having to affect the strategy or restart it. After closing the position, the strategy will continue to function normally and look for new trades to take
Increase Qty Button The increase Qty button allows to increase the quantity of the current active position by +1 contract
Decrease Qty Button The decrease Qty button allows to decrease the quantity of the current active position by -1 contract
Set Breakeven Button The button will set the stoploss of the open position to breakeven level if the current stoploss price is lower than breakeven price for long entries and higher than breakeven price for bearish entries.
Download & Installation Instructions

At automated-trading.ch you can chose to either purchase monthly subscription to use our premium products, or use our Free products without a premium subscription

In both cases, you need to create an account so you can get a License that you can use for both Premium and Free products

To obtain the license simply Signup and then get your license on the billing page

This CRT (Candle Range Theory) strategy is a premium strategy. It can be run on Backtest, Playback and Optimization modes for Free. Whereas an active subscription is required to run it on Live mode.

To download and install the strategy follow the instructions below

  • Click on the below download button to download the (CRT) Strategy file
  • This file was downloaded 13 times. Last download was 6 hours ago
  • Import the downloaded .zip file into NinjaTrader using the import NinjaScript menu item
  • how to import add on to NinjaTrader
  • Next, open a new chart window while making sure the Tick Replay tickbox is checked
  • image
  • If you don't see the Tick Replay check box, go to Tools->Options->Market Data and enable Show Tick Replay
  • image
  • After installing the strategy and opening a new Chart window you should add the strategy to the chart. Right-Click on the chart and Click on the the "Strategies" Context menu entry. Or you can Ctrl+S on the Chart to open the "Add New Strategy" Dialog window
    howto-add-strategy
    Click to enlarge
  • Make sure to check the Enabled check box
  • After adding the strategy to the chart, the strategy will be run on Historical data loaded in the chart.
  • When the Histocial data run is done, the strategy will switch to Real-Time mode and will add the license panel text box on the "Chart Trader Panel"
  • Make sure to display the Chart Trader panel on your active NinjaTrader Chart
  • image
  • Copy/Paste your license in the text box as shown in the image below. Your license can be found on the billing main page. Make sure to create an account or login first
  • Click on the Check License Button
  • image
  • At this step the strategy will check the License and activate/deactivate trading according to your subscription state
  • If you have an active subscription, will see the "Check License" button turned to green, and the next verification date next to your email. License check is only required once. Until the next verification date.
  • image
  • At this stage, the strategy is Ready. If your license is valid, the strategy will continue running on live mode
  • If you chose to not subscribe yet, and want to test the strategy beforehand, you can run it on Playback and Historical modes
Frequently Asked Questions
General
Do I need a VPS to run this strategy?

Using a VPS is good but not imperative. I run this strategy on a ~$6 VPS Windows instance on Hetzner. Check out our resources page to get a discount through our affiliate LINK

Can I run multiple instances of this strategy on the same account?

Yes! You can run multiple instances of this strategy on the same account but each instance should be run on a unique instrument

You can't run multiple instances on the same account on the same instrument because as you know NinjaTrader will aggregate orders in one position per instrument per account

Can I use a Trade Copier with this strategy?

Yes! you can use a copier, but a better solution would be to run multiple instances of the strategy. The purchased license allows you to run unlimited instances on multiple machines

Can I use this strategy to pass Apex or any other trader funding program?

Yes! The strategy is designed for that exact purpose. It will work seamlessly on Rithmic, NinjaTrader brokerage, Tradovate or any other provider connected to your NinjaTrader platform

Is this a hands-off, full-automatic strategy or does it need manual intervention and monitoring?

I designed this strategy to be full-automatic strategy. Yet, it can be used as a semi-auto strategy to enter trades and then let you manage those trades manually using its command buttons

Why should I consider full automated-trading instead of discretionary manual trading?

You should consider full auto-trading over manual trading for many reasons:

  • Trading 24/7: Automated trading strategies don't need to go to the bathroom not it need to take a break
  • Better execution, faster and more precise
  • Eliminate psychology and sentiments
  • Can be scaled to dozens if not hundreds of instances
  • Automated trading can generate truly "passive" income, manual trading is just another "more stressful" job

Can I ask you to modify/add a new feature to this strategy?

Yes, If you have an idea that you believe can improve the performance of this strategy, I will be more then happy to hear from you. Please use the contact page to send me a message

Will I get the source code of the strategy when I download it?

No, the source code of the strategy is protected for copyright reasons

Billing
Can I cancel my subscription at any time?

Yes, you can cancel your subscription from the account page at any time to prevent future payments. We cannot refund the unused portion of your subscription, but you will be able to use your subscription even after cancelling for the remainder of the billing cycle.

Is there a free trial period?

No, we don't offer a trial subscription plan. But you can download and test the strategy in backtest and playback modes before subscribing

What is the refund policy?

We do not offer full or partial refunds, but you may cancel your subscription at any time to stop future payments.

Skeptics
What is your background? Aren't you just another fake trading guru trying to sell me garbage?

I have been a professional software developer since 2010. I have been developing automated trading strategies since 2012, for my self for fun and profit and also been developing strategies for clients all over the world

I have always been invlolved professionaly in the business of Finance and Investing, I have worked for trading brokers and investment banking.

I'm not a marketer, and I don't hire someone else to develop my strategies.

If this strategy is profitable why are you selling it?

This strategy has been profitable for me on the long run with ups and downs, especially when it is run on multiple insturments. But the question remains pertinent, why I'm selling it?

The answer is I'm not selling it, I'm renting it to generate an additional income and diversify my different sources of income besides what this strategy can generate. Which you should also do. You should not rely on one source of income to reach financial independance, the key is diversification.

The edge of this strategy will not disappear if many people start using it. This strategy is purely mechanical and does not rely on a hidden quantitative pattern that should not be disclosed

Why the strategy uses Market orders and no Pending orders?

Lets examine pros and cons of pending orders

  • Pros:
    • Best price execution when using limit orders
    • Protection against losses in case of connectivity issues
  • Cons:
    • Can get rejected on high price volatility
    • Delay between request to place the order and when it gets placed. Price volatility can cause the order to be rejected and the price to run away
    • Requires management: any opposite orders need to be canceled
    • Visible to the broker, placed orders can be manipulated

After years of developing strategies I reached the conclusion that market orders are better suited for the context of automated trading.

The main drawback of using pending orders is the fact that they can be rejected which is very hard to manage especially in a volatile environment

In all our strategies, we use market orders even for take profit and stop loss. Lets examine the pros and cons of market orders

  • Pros:
    • Guarantee of execution reagrdless of volatility conditions
    • Invisible to the broker before they get submited
    • No risk of being rejected which means better protection for stop loss
    • Faster execution than pending orders
  • Cons:
    • In the case of the connection being lost with the broker, the strategy will be unable to send market orders

Remark: MIT (market if touched) orders in NinjaTrader are a solid alternative to pending orders if you really want to use pending orders

It is known that backtesting on NinjaTrader is not accurate. How accurate are your backtests?

We are following the NinjaTrader official guide on how to achieve precise intrabar granularity backtesting by using additional tick level DataSeries See here for more info

Don't take my word for it. Test it yourself, at the end of each trading day, run a backtest of the strategy on that day and compare it with the live trades the strategy made during the day.

Release Notes
Release 1.0.0.0 - 16 March 2025

  • First Release of the strategy

User Comments & Feedback

You can find feedback of our users and ask questions about this strategy by joining our discord community by following this invite link or clicking on the Discord logo image. Joining is completely free discord-invitation